[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
[APD] RE: MH lighting for 35 gallon tank
Steve Pushak writes:
"You DON'T want an MH light for a 35 gallon tank. Those are most suitable
for tanks over 100 gallons in size. You need about 35 to 40 watts of
fluorescent light, probably in a 2' U-shaped CF."
Well, I currently have more than that much light, and it's really not
enough. My current setup is two overdriven F15T8s, which while not as
efficient as a PCF, are quite visibly brighter than two NO F15T8s. So I have
to figure I'm getting at least the equivalent of 35W from a PCF.
As I mentioned, part of the problem is that the hex top includes a
rectangular window for the light to shine through. This creates a strange
lighting pattern that leaves the front and back poorly illuminated,
especially as you get closer to the top. Even in the middle of the tank, I
see problems with stem plants losing their lower leaves as they get shaded
by higher leaves.
I've seen people suggest 2W/g for non-CO2 tanks, but you're suggesting more
like 1W/g. I've also seen people recommend higher light levels for deeper
tanks, which this tank definitely is.
It seems as if I could DIY a setup with a 70W 6500K MH bulb (such as the
Iwasaki) in a bell-shaped pendant. That would give me 2W/g, and a nice
circular light pattern that would hit all of the corners. As a bonus I'd get
shadows and ripples.
Would I not want to do this because you think 70W is really too much light
for the tank, or because it would just be too outrageously expensive
compared to fluorescent solutions?
Aquatic-Plants mailing list
Aquatic-Plants at actwin_com