This list is horribly out of date, and really needs to be updated with some of the recent moves into online pet stores, such as Big Al's.
That Fish Place
237 Centerville Rd.
Lancaster, PA 17603
800-733-3829
The last of the "big four" on our list when we started the FAQ. That Pet Place/That Fish Place is a popular favorite.
Good Source for: Plants
Shipping: Actual Cost
Pet Warehouse has been recently sold to Drs. Smith and Foster. It remains to be seen how their availability and service will change.
[Redacted]
Wet Thumb Aquatic
52700 Base St.
New Baltimore, MI 48047
810-725-0960
Smaller outfit. Their selection is not great but prices are very good. They are more breeder oriented. They ship same day. Also, they happen to carry a great deal of merchandise, a lot that other companies do not even think about. Also, they are very willing to answer your questions.
Good Source for: Regenerative Blowers and Reverse Osmosis units.
End of Resource FAQ.