[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: [Killietalk] Another view on show participation




Dave S. wrote:
"With all due respect to Fred and others, if you're looking at breeding fish for the money, you're in the WRONG HOBBY".

That's true and especially for killifish. Just because some (including me) sell many of their fish at what they consider a fair price, does not imply a profit. Most killies go for $7 to $25 a pr other than at an auction frenzy where something very scarce (at that auction) and desirable by a couple of people. Even these few high auction prices are helping to cover losses incurred in other fish acquired for the auction. That is not a profit. Less money and it is not even a sale, but a subsity paid by the breeder so the buyer can buy more (or devote his or her money to another endeavor at the expense of the seller.) So often I hear "I can't afford $20 for a pr of fish" being stated by someone while drinking a $4 bottle of beer or $6 mixed drink. Sorry, but I don't earn enough at work to help subsidize a low spenders other hobbys or interests by selling my fish for a ton less than they cost me in money to raise. A fair price is also a means of establishing value to the buyer (something gotten cheap is of little value unfortunately due to human nature- --deny it if you wish, but then think again how you treated your last acquisitions) and it does provide some funds to the seller to continue to raise and buy killies to spread even more in the hobby. It's not a profit, just a partial subsidy for only costs, not for time and efforts, they are paid as love for the hobby.

Wright wrote:
"It makes for a "Catch 22" situation for the judges. They cannot choose
really young fish that have not fully developed, and older fish don't
move homes as readily. IMHO, there are some deep flaws in the process
that have not been fixed by some pretty smart folks."

That is why I made a suggestion as a possible alternative or even co-"show"
I would not have any problem donating a fish for "show" with my name firmly fixed to the tank. If all feel somehow leery of providing names that might somehow (I doubt it) influence judging, don't judge mine. I would be competing for pride, without eligibility for a trophy or show points. I would like to show the fruits of my efforts, but with some credit TO ME, affixed by viewers of my fish, not viewers of a trophy or award. Viewers might then know where they might get a young pair of the same strain.


Bill Shenefelt
http://sheneskillies.com/



Join the AKA at http://aka.org/modules/tinycontent0/index.php?id=9 Archives are at http://fins.actwin.com/killietalk/ Modify your subscription at http://www.actwin.com/mailman/listinfo.cgi/killietalk