[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

RE: Bad posts

>>Charles, I disagree wildly with your position.  I get 300 mails a day and 
I try to read and make sense of and answer any that ask for answers and 
learn from the rest.   I don't need any "I don't really know but maybe..." 
posts unless the subject is extremely difficult and the guess comes from a 
bona fide expert in the field.

In other words, if you don't know be quiet.   Maybe no one knows, then 
there will be no reply posted.   Maybe someone knows and posts,...  good! 
  But you do nothing to foster communications by posting a guess except in 
fields where you are expert.  OK?
- --
Dave Gomberg, San Francisco <<

With all due respect Dave, I disagree with you to a large extent. Granted 
what makes this list special are all the people who have many, many years 
of experience and scientific background, but this is a discussion forum, 
not a ask the experts for an answer forum. I hate to see anyone afraid to 
speak their opinions right or wrong, and this list can be quite intimada  
ting.  I dont think you realize how many people are on this list as passive 
observers who are active participants on other forums. Any time I post a 
question, I get many more responses privately from people who are afraid to 
post here publically, than I do from the list. I think thats rather sad. 
 Those that start with the "I dont really know, but.." means please dont 
yell at me!

Robert Paul  H
"Lots of good info and  plants for sale"
winner of the StudyWeb Academic Excellence Award
AB & Roger Williams Zoo
plants for sale