[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: Dupla CO2 indicator vs. CO2 test kits
> Date: Wed, 27 Aug 1997 12:49:32 -1000
> From: Wade Shimoda <wshimoda at hei_com>
> Could someone please explain the difference between the Dupla CO2
> indicator (I think Eheim also has a similar device) and a CO2 test
> kit? Does the Dupla indicator actually measure CO2 directly? When it
> indicates sufficient CO2, how much CO2 is in the water?
I'm making an educated guess, so take this with a grain of NaHCO3.
The CO2 indicator is showing the pH of the water vapor entering the
body of the indicator. The body contains a liquid indicator that
changes color around pH 7 (bromthymol blue ?). As such, it is
sensitive to the alkalinity of the water. I believe they recommend a
"KH" of around 3-5 degrees. I would hope that under the right
conditions, "good" is about 15 mg/l.
A CO2 test kit will titrate the sample water with sodium hydroxide
until all the dissolved CO2 (as carbonic acid) is converted to Na2CO3
at a pH of 8.3. Phenophthalein turns red at this pH, so it is used as
At least, I think so :-).