[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: [APD] Power Compact Bulb Useful Life: 12 months max
Just a reminder: one can be fooled with new fluorescent
bulbs. The more time the bulbs have been burning, the more
slowly the output degrades. The first few hundred hours
can give a roughly 10% drop, and the next 10% takes a year
or two. It doesn't really go in sudden steps; it's a
curve. MSome manufacturers rate the light output of their
bulbs after the initial burn-in period. This gives a lower
rating but results in a smaller percentage decrease one or
two years out.
New bulbs will almost always outshine old bulbs -- even
slightly old bulbs.
Which is not to say that your plants aren't happier getting
more light. But folks have used PCs for 2 years and more
and grown palnts nicely.
I think Tom Barr has a standing offer to accept anyone's
PCs if they are only a year or so old. I don't know if
he'll want the 2-year olds you have ;-)
--- Dave Millman <dave at tactics_com> wrote:
> My tank looked great for the first year. I sold lots of
> plants at the LFS
> and gave them away online, everybody was happy.
> The tank went steadily down hill during year two. The
> only good thing about
> that year was that I continuously improved all of my
> nutrient and
> cultivation techniques so that I'm doing everything
> pretty much perfectly
> now (50% weekly water change, Tom Barr's estimative index
> method). But the
> tank was still pure greenwater for months 22-23. Daphnia
> helped, but it was
> too much of a pain to keep them in the tank.
> So I borrowed a UV filter to clear the tank, and followed
> Tom Barr's advice
> to start at the beginning: Light.
> I bought four new 55W bulbs from AH Supply to replace my
> 23 month old ones.
> Guess what: Using the light meter in a professional video
> camera, I
> discovered that the difference in brightness between the
> new and old bulbs
> was much more than one f-stop. This means the old bulbs
> were putting out
> less than half the light the new ones were, at least in
> the frequencies to
> which the light meter is sensitive. While this imprecise
> test ignores the
> plant's spectral requirements, it still says to me that
> my tank went from
> over 3W per gallon to under 2W per gallon, while I was
> still dumping full
> nutrients in there. No wonder I had green water.
> Now the new bulbs are in, and the plants are pearling
> like mad. I haven't
> seen that in nearly a year.
> If anyone out there has the expertise and equipment to
> properly measure the
> output of my old bulbs, I would be happy to send them to
> you if you will
> publish a comparison with new bulbs. AHS or another
> vendor might even
> contribute a new bulb for comparison.
> I can't imagine why somebody would spend premium money
> for a CF fixture,
> then not replace the bulbs every 12 months.
See you in Dallas at the Aquatic Gardeners Associaton
2003 Annual Convention
Do you Yahoo!?
Protect your identity with Yahoo! Mail AddressGuard
Aquatic-Plants mailing list
Aquatic-Plants at actwin_com