[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: Algae challenge - and beyond
- To: Aquatic-Plants at actwin_com
- Subject: Re: Algae challenge - and beyond
- From: Paul Sears <psears at nrn1_NRCan.gc.ca>
- Date: Thu, 19 Jul 2001 21:32:13 -0400 (EDT)
- In-Reply-To: <200107191948.f6JJmcg14075 at actwin_com> from "Aquatic Plants Digest" at Jul 19, 2001 03:48:44 PM
> From: "Caleb Clapp" <caleb at cushingco_net>
> Subject: Algae Challange - and beyond (a.k.a. Newbie #2)
> Thank you all for your comments. Here is a brief response to some:
> TOM BARR responded:
> > I have used Seachem Alkaline Buffer with Acid Buffer to obtain KH 4 and
> PH 7.0.
> Why use acid(ahem) buffer? That's what the CO2 is for silly:)
> It's not what you want in a planted tank. The KH is good (alkaline buffer)
> but don't use the acid stuff. The CO2 takes care of all that. It will mess
> with the chart some. Therefore don't use it. You don't need it....Perhaps
> but you don't need it. You need to stop adding the acid buffer and
> let the CO2 do it's job. That's the pH thing(CO2 related, not acid buffers,
> CO2 is the THE acid!).
> This is my problem: my Boston tap water is very soft and its PH is very high
> (KH 2, GH 1.5, PH 8.4). If I add buffers to get my KH and GH up, won't my
> PH go sky High? Will CO2 alone, really bring it down? What about at night
> when the CO2 if off?.
Why turn it off at night? If you are adding bicarbonate, there
is no point, as Tom says, in adding any other buffer system. If you _do_
add other acids, what you are doing is destroying KH again. If it is a
strong acid you are adding, _all_ you are doing is destroying KH, if it
is a weak acid, you are making it impossible to measure KH or CO2 concentration.
> PAUL SEARS responded:
> From what I can see of Carbo-Plus, if it makes CO2 it does so
> from Ca++ and HCO3-, so you _must_ have adequate supplies of both. If
> you are using unknown buffers, you don't know how much KH you have
> (except that it is lower than your measurement).
> Stick to known materials - CaCO3 for GH and KH, NaHCO3 for KH.
> Hate to keep showing my ignorance, but would someone please remind me of the
> common names for these. Assuming I correctly buffer with KNOWN buffers, Am
> I likely to have any problem using the Carbo Plus with my very soft, high PH
> tap water?
The idea of the CaCO3 (calcium carbonate) is to make the water
harder and add KH. The NaHCO3 (baking soda) adds KH. If you have adequate
GH and KH, the way the water came out of the tap is irrelevant. Adding
other buffers would definitely be useless to the Carbo-Plus.
Paul Sears Ottawa, Canada