[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: Overfiltering

If nitrate levels increase, I would think there is excess ammonia not being 
used by plants.

Chuck Gadd mentioned in a post the other day that he replaced a substrate. 
For a short time there was a small amout of measurable nitrite and ammonia. 
This leads me to believe that much biological filtration is occurring right 
within the tank. If fish load is low enough, that would be enough. Since most 
people put more than a bare minimum of fish in, extra media providing surface 
for bacterial colonization is needed, and usually it's put in the filter. 

What I'm thinking is, whatever is in the tank (bacteria or plants) would get 
a first shot at utilizing the ammonia. If there is ammonia in the water going 
through the filter, bacteria in the filter will utilize the ammonia and grow. 
Isn't this so?

Meanwhile, I was sold on Diana Walstad's book by a previous poster who 
reported on her infrequent water changes yet apparently wonderful success 
with fish and plants. I am awaiting shipment. Perhaps there is a more 
in-depth explanation in there.


<< Well after reading Diana's book I'm actually giving this a try.  I have 
 plant growth but my nitrates do creep up.
 I'v removed all filter media out of my Fuval404 except for the sponges (want
 to keep the water clear of particles) so that it should have insuffient
 biological filtration for the tank.
 Will see if I can see any changes in plant growth and nitrate levels.
 Will of course keep a close eye on Ammonia levels :)